Adapting to the 2026 Medicare Advantage “Shakeup”
In October 2025, multiple industry reports confirmed that several large insurers will sharply cut back their Medicare Advantage (MA) offerings for 2026. For example, an October 1 Reuters report (via Yahoo Finance) noted that CVS Health’s Aetna arm will operate plans in 100 fewer counties next year, and Humana will cover just 85% of U.S. counties (down from 89% this year). A Healthcare Dive story on October 2, 2025 provided even more detail: UnitedHealthcare plans to exit 109 counties and drop one state from its MA map, Humana will leave three states and 194 counties, and Aetna (CVS) plans to leave one state and 100 counties. In short, the three biggest MA insurers are dramatically shrinking their footprints for 2026, while some smaller carriers (like Elevance/Anthem and Centene) are actually expanding coverage.
These announcements come as insurers cite tightening government reimbursements and rising costs. UnitedHealth Group, for example, said in a statement that “funding cuts, rising healthcare costs and increased utilization have created headwinds” for their Advantage business. In fact, Reuters reported that UHC expects Medicare payments to fall about 20% by 2026 (vs 2023 levels) due to new regulations. Industry watchers note that recent policy changes (like lower star-rating bonus payments) and unexpectedly high medical usage have squeezed profits in MA. At the same time, CMS projects that total MA enrollment will remain substantial in 2026 – around 34 million people (down slightly from ~35 million) – so there will still be lots of seniors in Advantage plans overall, just potentially with different insurers.
What this means for you:
If your current Medicare Advantage plan is withdrawn in your area, you won’t suddenly lose benefits – however, you will need to pick a new plan during next year’s open enrollment (likely in fall 2025) to maintain coverage. In practical terms, seniors in affected counties will have to choose among the remaining MA options (or return to Original Medicare + Medicare Drug Plan). For example, if UnitedHealthcare stops offering any MA plans in your county, you might have to switch to another carrier (perhaps a Blue Cross/Anthem or Humana plan) that still serves your area. The new plan could have a different network of doctors, co-pays, and premiums. In some cases, though, this could be a win – smaller carriers stepping in might compete by offering strong networks or lower prices. For instance, Kaiser Permanente is holding steady (it isn’t cutting states) and even expanding some plan types, and Humana will add new plan options in certain markets. So while change can be confusing, it also means more competition in many areas.
Steps to take now:
Seniors should prepare for the 2026 changes by reviewing your options early rather than waiting. Here are key actions:
- Check if your plan is affected. Insurers usually notify members if a plan is ending. Watch your mail or your insurer’s website this spring/summer to see if your county or state loses your current plan. You can also ask your insurance advisor or check the Medicare Plan Finder online.
- Compare new plans. Once you know any plan changes, use the Medicare Plan Finder or consult a local agent to scan all available 2026 plans in your county. Look at each option’s total cost (premiums + out-of-pocket limits), doctor/hospital network, and benefits. Pay special attention if you have preferred doctors or need certain drugs – make sure the new plan covers them.
- Consider networks and benefits. The largest changes may be in networks. A plan that replaces your old one might not include all the same doctors, or it might shift you from an HMO to a PPO (or vice versa). Review provider directories early. If cost savings from a lower premium are appealing, confirm that key specialists and hospitals are still covered. Also compare drug coverage: if your insurer also cut back Part D drug plans, you may need a standalone drug plan or find an MA plan that still covers your medications.
- Enroll on time. If you do switch plans, enroll during Medicare’s annual open enrollment (usually Oct 15 – Dec 7). Signing up by the deadline means your new coverage will start Jan 1, 2026 with no gap. (If you accidentally miss enrollment, you could be stuck with Original Medicare and a separate drug plan until the next enrollment period, which could be more expensive.)
- Get help from an advisor. Comparing many plans can be complicated. An independent agent or broker (for example, a local firm like Wilson & Co) can quickly gather side-by-side comparisons of all 2026 MA options in your area. Such an advisor can highlight plans that keep similar benefits or possibly lower your premium. They can also explain in plain language what each plan change means for you personally.
Remember, the final list of 2026 plans won’t be official until later in 2025 (insurers typically publish all their final offerings by late summer). But by acting now, you can tour potential alternatives. It’s often quicker and more efficient to do this well before open enrollment starts than to scramble at the last minute. If you work with a professional, the process is even smoother: an advisor can run comparisons and identify which plans maintain continuity. That efficiency gain means less stress for you, and knowing that you’ve taken charge of your coverage early can be a big relief.
Watch for competition and savings
In many counties, smaller insurers or local plans may step in where the big players left. This could be good news for seniors. More carriers in a market often means more plan choices – possibly plans that offer extra benefits (like fitness programs, extra dental coverage, or telehealth services) to attract members. In some cases, it might even help keep premiums from rising too much. Of course, any cost savings are not guaranteed; if a competitor offers a new plan, they might price it competitively. But it’s something to monitor: for example, some Humana drug plans are expected to have lower premiums in 2026. By reviewing all the options, you maximize the chance of finding a cheaper or more generous plan.
Stay informed and plan ahead
Keep an eye on reliable news sources and official CMS announcements over the coming months. The final MA rules for 2026 (e.g. payment rates and quality metrics) are usually released by CMS in the spring or summer. Any late changes could affect how many counties each insurer covers or how premiums are set. For now, focus on the confirmed news: major insurers are indeed retrenching their 2026 footprint. In practical terms, that means many seniors will be shopping for new plans this fall. By comparing options early and asking questions, you can minimize disruptions.
In summary
Don’t panic – plans that disappear will be replaced by other options. But do take this opportunity to review and possibly improve your coverage. An independent agent or counselor can guide you step-by-step. Our goal is to help you smoothly transition to the best available plan so that your benefits continue seamlessly and any cost changes are kept as small as possible. We will continue monitoring the Medicare Advantage landscape and share updates as 2026 approaches. Follow us for more straightforward insurance guidance, and feel free to reach out if you want a personalized review of your options. Together, we’ll make sure you’re covered next year with confidence and peace of mind.








